The FSMA 204 Delay and What the Food Traceability Rule Still Requires

Two people in hairnets look at romaine in an open carton in a cold receiving area, a leafy green FSMA 204 covers
Get in Touch

Reach out to our team for assistance with your legal and regulatory needs.

Table of Contents

If you have heard that the FSMA 204 date moved, you heard something true and something incomplete. Enforcement moved, because a spending law bars FDA from funding it before July 20, 2028. The Food Traceability Rule itself stayed in place, along with the records it requires and the conditions attached to its exemptions.

That is why I think the delay is as much a question for food and agriculture regulatory counsel as for the operations team.

FSMA 204 at a glance

The rule
Built on section 204 of the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act and codified at 21 CFR Part 1, Subpart S
Who it covers
Anyone who manufactures, processes, packs, or holds a food on the Food Traceability List
Enforcement
FDA proposed July 20, 2028, and Congress barred enforcement before that date
Records requests
All Subpart S records within 24 hours of an FDA request, or a reasonable time FDA agrees to

What the FSMA 204 delay changed and what it left alone

The FSMA traceability rule rests on section 204 of the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (21 U.S.C. 2223). That section directed FDA to designate high-risk foods and set added recordkeeping requirements for them. With those records, FDA can quickly identify who received a food and act to prevent or mitigate a foodborne illness outbreak.

FDA requested comments and data February 4, 2014, on designating high-risk foods for tracing.

FDA’s final rule took effect January 20, 2023, and is codified at 21 CFR Part 1, Subpart S. It set one compliance date for every covered entity, January 20, 2026.

On August 7, 2025, FDA proposed extending that date by 30 months, to July 20, 2028. In the same notice, FDA said the extension “does not amend, nor do we intend to amend, the requirements of the final rule.” As of September 23, 2026, no final rule adopting the extension has been published in the Federal Register.

Separately, Congress enacted Public Law 119-37 on November 12, 2025. Section 780 of the law bars FDA from using funds appropriated by that Act to administer or enforce the rule before July 20, 2028. FDA says it “intends to comply with this Congressional directive.”

Section 780 limits how FDA may use appropriated funds, and it does not amend the statute or the regulation. FDA also says it is still developing its enforcement and compliance strategy, and it has published no start date for routine inspections under the rule. On June 15, 2026, FDA held a public meeting on lot-level food traceability and took comments through July 15, 2026.

The accurate FSMA 204 summary is narrower than what circulates. FDA proposed July 20, 2028, and Congress separately barred enforcement of the rule before that same date. Unless FDA changes them, the requirements are the ones in the regulation today.

Is your product on the Food Traceability List?

The rule applies to anyone who manufactures, processes, packs, or holds a food on the Food Traceability List (21 CFR 1.1300). FDA publishes the list on its website, and its current categories are grouped below by type of food.

  • Cheeses, eggs, and nut butters. Soft and semi-soft cheeses, cheeses made from unpasteurized milk other than hard cheese, shell eggs, and nut butters.
  • Fresh produce. Cucumbers, herbs, leafy greens, melons, peppers, sprouts, tomatoes, and tropical tree fruits.
  • Fresh-cut fruits and vegetables. Fresh-cut leafy greens, fresh-cut fruits, and fresh-cut vegetables other than leafy greens.
  • Fish and shellfish. Finfish (fresh, frozen, and previously frozen), smoked finfish, crustaceans, and molluscan shellfish (bivalves).
  • Deli salads. Refrigerated ready-to-eat deli salads.

For manufacturers, the finished product is often the harder call. The list also covers foods that contain a listed food as an ingredient (21 CFR 1.1310). The ingredient must stay in the form the list names, such as fresh.

In FDA’s examples, a bagged salad mix with fresh lettuce is covered, and so is a sandwich with fresh tomato slices. A frozen pizza with spinach topping is not. Peanut butter in a sandwich cracker with no kill step applied is covered.

Form matters at the edges too. Frozen spinach, dried peppers, and dried herbs fall outside the list, while finfish, crustaceans, and molluscan shellfish are covered fresh and frozen. IMS-listed Grade “A” cottage cheese was exempted effective February 20, 2026 (91 FR 8256), but registered facilities still keep one-up, one-back records for it.

The list itself can change. Deletions take effect immediately and additions two years after FDA’s Federal Register notice, unless the notice says otherwise (21 CFR 1.1465(c)).

Which FSMA 204 traceability records belong to your company

The rule builds its records around Critical Tracking Events, and Key Data Elements are the information you must record for each one. Each record must be kept two years after it is created or obtained (21 CFR 1.1455(d)). Which events you own depends on what you physically do with the food (21 CFR 1.1310 and 1.1325 through 1.1350).

Critical Tracking EventWho performs it
harvestingFarms
coolingWhoever cools a raw agricultural commodity before initial packing
initial packingWhoever first packs a raw agricultural commodity
first land-based receivingWhoever first takes possession on land of food from a fishing vessel
shipping, receiving, and transformationAny covered person who ships, receives, or transforms a listed food

Generally, traceability lot codes may be assigned at only three events (21 CFR 1.1320). Those events are initial packing, first land-based receiving, and transformation, so no new lot code may be created at other steps such as shipping.

The exception is food from an exempt supplier. If that food is on the Food Traceability List and arrives without a lot code, the receiver must assign one (21 CFR 1.1345(b)(1)). Retail food establishments and restaurants are excused from that requirement.

Transformation reaches further than its name suggests. It includes manufacturing or processing a food, or changing the food or its packaging, when the output is a listed food. The rule gives commingling, repacking, and relabeling as examples (21 CFR 1.1310).

Shipments between two of your own locations at different street addresses also count as shipping and receiving (21 CFR 1.1310). Under 21 CFR 1.1340, the shipper of each lot keeps eight Key Data Elements and must send the first seven to the next recipient.

  1. Traceability lot code
  2. Quantity and unit of measure
  3. Product description
  4. Immediate next recipient’s location, not the transporter’s
  5. Location shipped from
  6. Date shipped
  7. Lot code source location, or a reference to it such as an FDA food facility registration number or web address
  8. Reference document type and number

The receiver keeps eight matching elements (21 CFR 1.1345(a)). Your records depend on data your trading partners hand you, and theirs depend on yours.

FSMA 204 exemptions that hold only with the right paperwork

Some exemptions in 21 CFR 1.1305 turn on simple status. Transporters and 501(c)(3) nonprofit food establishments are exempt, as are retail food establishments and restaurants with average annual food sales of no more than $250,000. That figure, like the other dollar thresholds below, is a 3-year rolling average adjusted for inflation, and FDA has not yet posted the adjusted values.

Other exemptions hold only if a record or document exists and can be produced. Those are the ones I would test first.

  • Kill-step foods. A kill step is lethality processing that significantly minimizes pathogens. Food you put through a kill step is exempt from the rest of the rule only if you keep a record of applying it. The exemption also depends on keeping your receiving records for that food, unless a qualifying written agreement covers it (21 CFR 1.1305(d)(3)).
  • Foods changed off the list. Fresh spinach that becomes frozen is one example. The exemption holds only if you keep receiving records for the food you changed, unless a qualifying written agreement covers it (21 CFR 1.1305(d)(4)).
  • Downstream written agreements. Sometimes a later company will apply the kill step or change the food. If that company is not a retailer, restaurant, or consumer, the shipper’s exemption depends on a written agreement with the receiver. It must carry an effective date, the parties’ printed names and signatures, and its substance. Both parties must keep it while it is in effect, and it must be renewed at least once every three years (21 CFR 1.1305(d)(6)).

Several partial exemptions still carry a record (21 CFR 1.1305). A retailer or restaurant that buys directly from a farm, for example, keeps the farm’s name and address for 180 days. Registered facilities that handle exempt commingled raw agricultural commodities keep one-up, one-back records for two years.

What happens when FDA asks for your records

FDA investigators may request traceability records in a range of situations, including routine inspections, outbreak investigations, recalls, and other threats to public health. Under 21 CFR 1.1455(c)(1), you must make all Subpart S records available within 24 hours of a request. The deadline can instead be a reasonable time that FDA agrees to.

You must also provide whatever is needed to understand the records. That can include internal or external coding systems, glossaries, abbreviations, and a description of how the records match the rule’s requirements.

FDA may need the records to prevent or mitigate a foodborne illness outbreak, help carry out a recall, or address another public health threat. In those cases FDA can ask in person or remotely, including by phone. The 24-hour clock runs from the phone request (21 CFR 1.1455(c)(3)).

For those requests, the Key Data Elements must arrive as an electronic sortable spreadsheet (21 CFR 1.1455(c)(3)(ii)). A routine inspection outside those conditions requires no spreadsheet. Smaller entities may use a form other than a sortable spreadsheet.

The alternative is open to farms with average annual raw agricultural commodity sales of no more than $250,000 (21 CFR 1.1455(c)(3)(iii)). Retail food establishments, restaurants, and other persons also qualify when their average annual food sales are no more than $1 million.

You may have another entity keep your records (21 CFR 1.1455(b)). You remain responsible, though, for making sure they can be retrieved and provided onsite within 24 hours of a request.

Whoever holds the records, the traceability plan is what explains them, and in my view it is the most important document in the file. Under 21 CFR 1.1315(a), every covered person must keep a written plan that describes the following.

  • How records are maintained, including their format and location
  • How listed foods are identified among the foods you handle
  • How lot codes are assigned, if you assign them
  • A named point of contact for questions about the plan and records
  • A farm map showing each field or growing area with geographic coordinates (for aquaculture, each pond, tank, or cage), for anyone who grows or raises a listed food other than eggs

FDA requires no specific format for the plan, but it must be updated as needed to reflect current practices (21 CFR 1.1315(b)). You must keep the previous version for two years after each update.

The rule also states its consequences. Violating any Subpart S recordkeeping requirement is a prohibited act under section 301(e) of the FD&C Act (21 CFR 1.1460(a)). The one exception is a violation committed by a farm.

An imported food is subject to refusal of admission if it appears the requirements were not met (21 CFR 1.1460(b)). FDA may also hold more than one entity responsible for the same recordkeeping failure.

FDA says it generally gives firms a chance to correct voluntarily and may issue Untitled Letters and Warning Letters. The federal government may bring civil injunction actions or criminal prosecutions. OFW Law’s FDA compliance guide explains how escalation generally works.

Why a traceability platform cannot settle the question alone

FSMA 204 enforcement feels years away, so waiting to start on records, agreements, and exemptions can seem sensible. In my view, the slowest parts of this work depend on other companies and on legal judgment. A later enforcement date makes none of that work faster.

Written agreements need a signature from the other company. Lot codes have to be assigned at the right events and passed along intact by suppliers and customers. Exemption positions have to be tested against 21 CFR 1.1305.

Waiting can also look sensible when a software vendor says its platform makes the company compliant. The statute says the rule may not prescribe specific technologies for keeping records (21 U.S.C. 2223(d)(1)(C)).

A platform can store and sort data well. It cannot sign your agreements, decide whether your kill-step exemption holds, or write a plan that describes how your company works.

FDA’s own testing points the same way. FDA ran traceability readiness tabletop exercises across six supply chains between March 9 and April 1, 2026. Most firms responded within 24 hours, and FDA reported that supply chain coordination, more than any particular technology, drove the strongest results.

The lot code data from FDA’s exercise showed gaps.

40%of participants' records captured the properly assigned lot code across each event they performed
27%of participants' records captured the complete lot code source for each event

Six supply chains is a small exercise, so I would read the percentages carefully. The findings are still FDA’s own.

Traceability records can also matter in federal civil litigation, where parties may obtain discovery of any nonprivileged matter relevant to any party’s claim or defense. Discovery must also be proportional to the needs of the case. Information need not be admissible to be discoverable (Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(1)).

In my professional judgment, the other side in a foodborne illness lawsuit involving a listed food is likely to request the traceability records. I would expect the plan that explains them and any agreement behind an exemption to be requested too. Those documents should tell a consistent story before anyone asks.

How OFW Law advises on traceability records and FDA requests

OFW Law is a Washington, DC law firm that represents food and agriculture companies on FDA and USDA regulatory matters and defends them in litigation. That pairing matters here, because traceability records are regulatory documents that can also become evidence.

A records review for FSMA 204 compliance checks whether your Critical Tracking Events and Key Data Elements match what your company actually does. That includes relabeling or repacking, which can count as transformation. It also checks that lot codes are assigned only where 21 CFR 1.1320 allows.

For each exemption you rely on, the question is which condition in 21 CFR 1.1305 applies and which document shows you meet it.

Your response plan should include a current traceability plan and a working path to a sortable spreadsheet. It should also name a point of contact who knows the 24-hour clock can start with a phone call.

What the delay buys is the chance to settle each question deliberately. It also leaves room to fix what the review finds and to bring your suppliers and customers along. To have your FSMA 204 traceability records, exemption positions, and response plan reviewed while your options are open, contact OFW Law or call 202-933-5394.

Contact OFW Law

FSMA 204 frequently asked questions

Is there a delay in the FSMA 204 compliance date?

FDA has proposed moving the compliance date from January 20, 2026 to July 20, 2028. The proposal dates from August 7, 2025, and no final rule adopting it has been published as of September 23, 2026. Separately, Congress barred FDA from using funds appropriated by Public Law 119-37 to administer or enforce the rule before July 20, 2028.

What foods are on the FSMA 204 Food Traceability List?

Most categories on the list are fresh produce or seafood. The rest are certain cheeses, shell eggs, nut butters, and refrigerated ready-to-eat deli salads. Form matters as well, with frozen spinach and dried herbs outside the list and nut butters covered in every form.

Does a product that contains a listed food fall under FSMA 204?

It can. A food with a listed food as an ingredient is covered if that ingredient stays in its listed form (21 CFR 1.1310). A prepared smoothie with fresh cantaloupe is covered, while trail mix with dried papaya is not.

What records does the food traceability rule require?

A covered company keeps a written traceability plan (21 CFR 1.1315) and the Key Data Elements for each Critical Tracking Event it performs. Records are kept for two years and produced within 24 hours of an FDA request (21 CFR 1.1455). For outbreak, recall, and other public health threat requests, the Key Data Elements go in an electronic sortable spreadsheet unless a smaller-entity alternative applies.

Who is exempt from FSMA 204?

Small produce farms and other raw agricultural commodity producers with no more than $25,000 in average annual sales are fully exempt (21 CFR 1.1305). So are shell egg producers with fewer than 3,000 laying hens at a farm, and transporters, among others. Several others hold only if the required records or written agreements exist.

Does FSMA 204 require specific traceability software?

No, the statute says the rule may not prescribe specific technologies for keeping records (21 U.S.C. 2223(d)(1)(C)). Records may be paper or electronic (21 CFR 1.1455(a)(1)). FDA reported from its 2026 tabletop exercises that supply chain coordination, more than any particular technology, drove the strongest results.

Disclaimer: The content provided on this blog is intended for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. The information presented by OFW Law is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. While we strive to provide accurate and timely information regarding our practice areas, laws and regulations change frequently; therefore, we cannot guarantee that all information is current or applicable to your specific situation. You should not act or refrain from acting on the basis of any content included in this site without seeking the appropriate legal or other professional advice on the particular facts and circumstances at issue from an attorney licensed in your state. All liability with respect to actions taken or not taken based on the contents of this site is hereby expressly disclaimed.